How Davy D. Xebec Surpassed Gol D. Roger in Power and Legacy
Xebec vs. Roger: A Rivalry That Redefines One Piece History
Xebec vs Roger One Piece: How Xebec Surpassed Roger
For more than twenty years, One Piece fans saw Gol D. Roger as the ultimate benchmark of pirate supremacy. He was the only man to reach Laugh Tale, uncover the legendary treasure, and ignite the Great Pirate Era. However, this long-standing perception shifted dramatically when Eiichiro Oda unveiled the full truth behind the God Valley Incident and introduced the most enigmatic figure in the entire series: Davy D. Xebec.
The flashback did more than expand the world’s lore—it shook the foundation of what fans believed about Roger’s place at the top. Xebec’s portrayal revealed a figure so immense, so overwhelming in ambition, and so historically disruptive that many now argue he left a wider, more earth-shattering mark on the world than the Pirate King himself.
What makes this revelation incredible is that it isn’t even fan exaggeration. With his backstory now complete, we finally have enough information to compare these two legendary figures and understand why Xebec carved a legacy far more violent, radical, and transformative than Roger’s.
A Forgotten Lineage: Xebec as the Descendant of Davy Jones
One of the most stunning revelations of the God Valley flashback is the truth about Xebec’s ancestry. He descended directly from Davy Jones, a mythical figure said to have once ruled the world in a distant era. When Xebec reveals his name to Imu—the supreme sovereign—the reaction is not fear, but rage. This moment alone signals how dangerous Xebec truly was.
What makes his story even more compelling is that he had abandoned his lineage and lived as an ordinary man. Only when his ambition resurfaced did he step back into the heart of global conflict, becoming the most destabilizing adversary the World Government had ever faced.
The Impossible Feat: Infiltrating Marijoa During the Reverie
Xebec’s defining moment is not merely extraordinary—it is unprecedented. His infiltration of Marijoa during the Reverie stands as one of the boldest acts ever recorded in One Piece. The Reverie period represents the highest global security alert, with Admirals, CP0, and elite guardians surrounding the holy land.
Yet Xebec didn’t just sneak in.
He kidnapped multiple monarchs, killed a serving Admiral, confronted Imu face-to-face, and survived the encounter.
As noted by various One Piece analyses, not even Roger, Whitebeard, Kaido, or Big Mom could have attempted such an impossible mission. This single act became the cornerstone of Xebec’s legend—an attack aimed directly at the core of the world’s ruling class.
The Rocks Pirates: The Most Terrifying Crew in One Piece
After the Marijoa incident, Xebec completed another impossible achievement: assembling the greatest pirate crew in history. The Rocks Pirates consisted of:
-
Whitebeard
-
Big Mom
-
Kaido
-
Shiki
-
And several other monstrous figures
Every one of them would one day become a world-shaking entity. Yet in their youth, they recognized Xebec as their captain. This fact alone demonstrates the magnitude of Xebec’s charisma, power, and influence.
No other pirate—past or present—has ever commanded personalities of such overwhelming dominance. That they followed Xebec proves he was not just powerful; he was irresistibly formidable.
The Man Behind the Legend: A Blend of Ferocity and Humanity
While One Piece often portrays Xebec as a tyrant, the flashback reveals a more nuanced character. Beneath the fearsome reputation, Xebec showed real loyalty and affection toward his allies. He protected his companions, honored his bonds, and genuinely loved his family.
His return to God Valley was not driven by madness or revenge—it was driven by the desire to save the people he cared about.
This human dimension adds depth to his character. It shows that he wasn’t born a monster—he became a victim of fate, ambition, and the oppressive structures surrounding him. His tragedy lies in the fact that the world viewed him as a catastrophe, even though his motivations were rooted in belief and conviction.
The Cruel End: When Xebec Became a Demon
Xebec’s downfall is one of the darkest moments in the series. After defeating Saint Figarland Garling and even managing to land a devastating blow against Imu, Xebec falls victim not to an enemy’s ambition, but to a supernatural force.
Through the horrific power of the Domi Reversi, Xebec is transformed into a mindless demon—stripped of his will and turned into a weapon of destruction. He doesn’t die as the rebellious pirate who challenged the gods, but as a cursed creature manipulated by the highest powers of the world.
Only the combined might of Roger and Garp manages to bring an end to his torment.
This ending doesn’t diminish his legacy.
It magnifies it.
Xebec wasn’t defeated by a rival pirate—he was erased by the world’s ultimate power.
Who Will Surpass Xebec? The Next Bearers of His Will
Despite Xebec’s overwhelming legacy, two figures stand poised to surpass him: Monkey D. Luffy and Marshall D. Teach, Xebec’s own descendant.
Marshall D. Teach (Blackbeard)
Teach dreams of ruling the entire world, mirroring Xebec’s ambition. With multiple Devil Fruits and three Road Poneglyphs already secured, he has built tremendous momentum toward that goal.
Monkey D. Luffy
On the opposite end, Luffy seeks freedom, not domination. Gifted with the Sun God’s will and three Road Poneglyphs, he is positioned as the only individual capable of breaking the world’s oppressive system—and reaching Laugh Tale.
Their inevitable clash will determine not just the next Pirate King, but the future shape of the world itself.
Xebec Tried to Break the System—Roger Simply Navigated It
The contrast between Roger and Xebec defines their legacies:
-
Roger found freedom and encouraged others to seek it.
-
Xebec tried to shatter the entire system that oppressed the world.
Roger’s journey inspired a new age.
Xebec’s crusade threatened to rewrite the world order entirely.
In terms of ambition, political impact, and global disruption, Xebec surpassed Roger. But the world wasn’t ready for someone so powerful, so rebellious, and so uncontainable.
Now, the responsibility of reshaping history falls to Luffy and Teach—the only two men capable of carrying Xebec’s titanic legacy even further.
Xebec vs Roger One Piece: How Xebec Surpassed Roger. Xebec vs Roger One Piece: How Xebec Surpassed Roger. Xebec vs Roger One Piece: How Xebec Surpassed Roger. Xebec vs Roger One Piece: How Xebec Surpassed Roger. Xebec vs Roger One Piece: How Xebec Surpassed Roger. Xebec vs Roger One Piece: How Xebec Surpassed Roger. Xebec vs Roger One Piece: How Xebec Surpassed Roger. Xebec vs Roger One Piece: How Xebec Surpassed Roger. Xebec vs Roger One Piece: How Xebec Surpassed Roger. Xebec vs Roger One Piece: How Xebec Surpassed Roger. Xebec vs Roger One Piece: How Xebec Surpassed Roger. Xebec vs Roger One Piece: How Xebec Surpassed Roger. Xebec vs Roger One Piece: How Xebec Surpassed Roger. Xebec vs Roger One Piece: How Xebec Surpassed Roger. Xebec vs Roger One Piece: How Xebec Surpassed Roger. Xebec vs Roger One Piece: How Xebec Surpassed Roger.
